Why Feature Toggles Could Be Your Front-End's Worst Nightmare

Feature toggles (or feature flags) have become a fundamental part of front-end development. They provide a way to dynamically enable or disable features without deploying new code, making it possible to run A/B tests, roll out features gradually, or easily turn off problematic functionality. However, with all the benefits they bring, feature toggles can also lead to serious challenges.

The Hidden Complexity of Feature Toggles

When you start using feature toggles in a front-end project, everything may seem straightforward: add a toggle, check its value, and determine if a feature should run or not. But as your project scales and you add more toggles, the complexity increases exponentially. Here are some of the common problems that arise:

1. Configuration Overload: A small project might have only a handful of toggles, but larger applications can have dozens or even hundreds. Managing which toggles are on, off, or in some intermediate state becomes cumbersome. Developers might have to juggle multiple configurations for different environments, making debugging more difficult.

2. Interdependencies Between Features: A more insidious problem comes from the way features interact. Features that are meant to be toggled independently can have hidden dependencies. If one toggle changes the behavior of a shared component, another feature relying on that component might break in unexpected ways. It becomes harder to reason about the codebase, and simple changes can have unintended consequences.

3. Codebase Fragmentation: As you add feature toggles, your code starts to split into different execution paths based on toggle states. Over time, this can make the codebase hard to navigate. You may have conditional checks scattered throughout, and the readability and maintainability of the code suffer. Refactoring becomes a dangerous task, as ensuring all toggle states are handled correctly is tricky and error-prone.

4. Testing Challenges: To confidently release new features, you must test the application in all possible toggle configurations. As the number of toggles grows, the combinations become unmanageable. Even if you automate testing, it can become prohibitively expensive to cover every scenario, especially as features are turned on and off.

5. Performance Overhead: Feature toggles can also introduce performance issues. Checking a toggle’s state isn’t costly on its own, but when many toggles are checked repeatedly in the render process, it can degrade performance. Moreover, toggles often require infrastructure for configuration, increasing the load on your backend.

How Do We Manage Feature Toggle Complexity?

Handling feature toggles well requires thoughtful strategies and sometimes specialized tools. Some approaches include:

• Centralizing Configuration: Instead of sprinkling toggle logic throughout your codebase, try to centralize it. Use a dedicated service or module to manage the state of all toggles and handle complex dependencies in one place.
• Strict Dependency Management: Carefully track which features depend on others. Document these relationships and, if possible, enforce constraints in code to ensure that features are toggled in a way that makes sense.
• Automated Testing and Analysis: Invest in automated tools that can analyze toggle coverage. Some systems can warn you when a change might break an existing toggle configuration or generate test cases for common scenarios.
• Periodic Cleanup: Feature toggles shouldn’t live forever. Once a feature is stable and rolled out to all users, remove the toggle and the associated logic to simplify the codebase. A regular cleanup process can help prevent “toggle bloat.”

Introducing app-compose: A New Way to Manage Dependencies

When feature toggles are used in an application with many interdependent parts, managing these dependencies can feel overwhelming. This is where a tool like app-compose can help.

app-compose allows you to define features as isolated containers, each with explicit dependencies. Instead of having to manually track which features are ready or handle complex chains of conditions, app-compose orchestrates everything for you. By using app-compose, you can ensure that features only initialize when their dependencies are in the right state, significantly reducing the risk of hidden bugs or runtime errors.

Here’s a simple example of how app-compose can simplify dependency management:

import { createContainer, compose } from '@grlt-hub/app-compose'

const fetchToggles = () => ({ referral: false });

const featureToggle = createContainer({
  id: 'featureToggle',
  start: async () => {
    const data = await fetchToggles();

    return { api: { data } };
  },
});

const referral = createContainer({
  id: 'referral',
  dependsOn: [featureToggle],
  enable: (deps) => deps.featureToggle.data.referral,
  start: () => ({ api: null }),
});

await compose.up([featureToggle, referral]);

Explanation:

• fetchToggles: Fetches the feature toggles and returns an object indicating whether each feature is enabled or disabled.
• featureToggle: A container that fetches the toggles. The data is made available via its api.
• referral: A container that depends on featureToggle. It checks if the referral feature is enabled using the enable method. If the feature is not enabled, the referral container will not start.

With app-compose, taming the complexity of feature toggles becomes not just manageable but structured and efficient.

Docs
GitHub repo