DEV Community

Horace FAYOMI
Horace FAYOMI

Posted on • Edited on

The art and difficulty of naming in programming

#programming #beginners #codenewbie #codereview

Important note: Do not read any of the comments in the thread without solving the challenge.

This article is a follow of my very first article
Every programmer should know these conventions and practices.

So in this article, I'll develop a little more in-depth the point: Give meaningful names.

Giving a meaningful name to our variables, functions, arguments, classes, attributes, and packages is both difficult and an art. Sometimes, and even often, every developer who cares about code quality stumbles upon naming issues. Personally, I can spend a lot of time just thinking about what will the best name for this, and I can choose one, change it later, multiple times until I find one or a colleague helps me to find the one that satisfied me the most, the one that makes me say or think, yeah, that is the perfect name.
Because, the name could drastically change how easily other developers and you (later, in a few years maybe ^_^) will quickly understand your code without necessary reading the details.

In this article, I'll just try to show you the impact of bad names and give more insights and concrete examples in a part2.

I want you to quickly determine without testing what the function does, and after that, find better names to replace the badly named variables in that function in order to make the function more readable and understandable. It's the function in the picture below, it's written in python.
You can start now, and read the rest of the article after you’re done. Are you ready to take the challenge?

So let's go:

Simple function poorly named in python
The 20 seconds starts right now !!!

Congrats. No matter how much time you took to find it, 10seconds, or 1min, you agree with me that, after you've changed the variable's names with good ones, the function is more obvious to comprehend.
But you know, in reality, even the poorest developer can't write a code that is that much awful, at least, I hope so. In a part 2 of this article, I'll show some real example cases of code naming improvement and best practices.

We are at the end of this short article. Feel free to add in the comments some real cases of naming issues you faced and which name you finally chose.

I share what I know because:

The more I learn, the more I realize how much I don't know. (Einstein)

Top comments (11)

Collapse
 
fayomihorace profile image
Horace FAYOMI •

I drop the solution here anyways.

def print_items_counts(array):
    item_map_count = {}
    for item in array:
        if item_map_count.get(item):
            item_map_count[item] += 1
        else:
            item_map_count[item] = 1

    for item, count in item_map_count.items():
        print(f"{item}: {count}")
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
Collapse
 
geraldew profile image
geraldew •

If we're talking about clarity then it is misleading to use

 if item_map_count.get(item):
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

when there is no apparent use for that value. Instead it is clearer to use

 if item in item_map_count :
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

So it's not just choice of variable names that affect clarity.

Collapse
 
fayomihorace profile image
Horace FAYOMI •

You're right geraldew, thanks.

Collapse
 
yannickkiki profile image
yannickkiki • • Edited

Nice article, waiting for the part 2!

Just for the record, we could also write this part

if item_map_count.get(item):
    item_map_count[item] += 1
else:
    item_map_count[item] = 1
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

as this

item_map_count[item] = 1 + item_map_count.get(item, 0)
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
Collapse
 
fayomihorace profile image
Horace FAYOMI •

Beautiful indeed, I like shorthands. Thanks.

Collapse
 
fayomihorace profile image
Horace FAYOMI •

And the same thing could be achieved using build in python library collections.Counter like this:

collections.Counter(array)
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
Collapse
 
jonaspetri profile image
Jonas Petri •

That was a great article!
It took me a while to figure out what the program actually did, just because of how poorly the variables were named.

Collapse
 
fayomihorace profile image
Horace FAYOMI •

Thanks Jonas.

Collapse
 
ooling profile image
Sam oo Líng •

Great! I'm waiting for part 2

Collapse
 
fayomihorace profile image
Horace FAYOMI •

Thanks Sammy. Don't, it will come ^_^.

Collapse
 
tomasforsman profile image
Tomas Forsman •

This was not really an example of simply bad naming, this was intentionally misleading naming with "booleans".

Here is how I would set bad names:

def process_list(lst):
    result_dict = {}
    for item in lst:
        if result_dict.get(item):
            result_dict[item] += 1
        else:
            result_dict[item] = 1

    for key, value in result_dict.items():
        print(f"{key}: {value}")
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

And here is how far I could take this with help from the other comments. Perhaps a bit overkill...

from collections import Counter
from typing import List, Any

def print_item_counts(array: List[Any]) -> None:
    """
    Print the count of each item in the input array.

    Args:
        array (List[Any]): The list of items to be counted.

    Example:
        >>> print_item_counts(['apple', 'banana', 'apple'])
        apple: 2
        banana: 1
    """
    if not array:
        print("The array is empty.")
        return

    item_count = Counter(array)
    for item, count in item_count.items():
        print(f"{item}: {count}")
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

I know Docstring isn't part of this but for the sake of a clarity example I included it; not for readability (it actually makes the code a bit less readable imho) but for documentation and IDE tooling.

Reminder to post the next part 😀

View full discussion (11 comments)

Read next

trixsec profile image

Part 12: Building Your Own AI - Model Evaluation and Tuning for Optimal Performance

Trix Cyrus -

trixsec profile image

Essential Arch Linux Commands: Advanced Mastery(Part-2)[Must Read]

Trix Cyrus -

gliimly profile image

Distributed computing made easy

Gliimly -

mdarifulhaque profile image

1792. Maximum Average Pass Ratio

MD ARIFUL HAQUE -