Look at the GIF below — it shows a real-time Todo-MVC demo, syncing across windows and smoothly transitioning in and out of offline mode. While it’...
For further actions, you may consider blocking this person and/or reporting abuse
Amazing thanks for this - I've been considering exactly the same port so really nice to see this and have your thoughts. I've been tinkering with SQLite Cloud as an alternative but I'm not clear it's local first.
Helpful to see another implementation of svelte-SSE too as think I'll need the same for sqlite cloud.
Good luck @ccozens! I don't think it matters that much whether something is "local first" or not. I care more about which problem that thing solves. In other words, don't let that stop you :)
Great article. Only bad part is that it enlightens me about some lacks in my apps. As you mentioned, the solutions are not trivial ... but they could easily head off future problems.
We use the ThingsDB rooms concept to achieve this in our infrastructure monitoring and this works like a charm.
If anyone is interested ThingDB is fully open source and we have a free ebook explaining this concept which is freely available to anyone interested.
Edit:
We just made the book available online, see this chapter for our rooms concept.
Good one thanks
Very nice article! Really interesting concept.
Thank for the post. It's amaizng!!
Great article! I appreciate your view points. I do believe PWAs are the future of building native apps and the whole Web will operate this way one day. One codebase to rule them all! Lol...If you design with careful intent and not on pushing for speed you can accomplish amazing things using vanilla JS, CSS, HTML! I built my own client side sync library leveraging service Worker, broadcast channel, local storage, indexed db, background sync. After app installation any action you perform is instantaneous. It's a enterprise grade sales quoting tool and our entire Salesforce loves it! I think if developers focus more on the right tool for the right job and less on what framework will make their lives easier you'll see an explosion of amazing things on the web!
Cool! I considered building a toy version of Replicache myself as an exercise. Is the tool you built open source?
Not yet
In my opinion, these are not problems waiting to be solved by a framework. These are go-to (default) features already integrated into a well-built system. Figma and the other examples here are good examples of well-built software, state of the art, if I may.
My point is, dev teams should strive to achieve all these into their software without using a framework for that. Being well built includes these.
my goal here was to introduce the ideas as well as a good implementation of them (Replicache). I agree that it is possible to implement something like that on your own, whether it's smart or not depends on your specific situation
Sure. My point was that people should focus on delivering quality software which in fact should come with all these by default. Not everything should be “solved” with a framework.
The need for such a framework merely shows how low the qualify of the software delivered today is, by the average developer. I mean look at the comments! You have people saying you enlightened them and now they can see what they did wrong. Proves my point that there’s are so few good engineers and probably more than 90% are average or below, delivering software not thought from all angles.
But by all means, your article is good and never have I said my ideas are contradicting with yours, I said it in my first comment, it is just my opinion. :)
Yjs is an awesome CRDT library that enables apps to resolve differences and update in real time. It also enables offline first use and is perfect for collaborative rich text editing. And it's open source. That said it does have a learning curve. We use it very effectively in our PKM Clibu Notes - clibu.com
I heard great things about Yjs but is it good in the general case (outside of text)? A common criticism is that you can control what the CRDTs converge to and sometimes they don't converge on the desired outcome
Interesting comment. I've not heard or witnessed any issues where the desired outcome isn't what is expected. That said, even though I've read a fair bit about CRDTs I don't profess to fully understand how they do the magic they do.
Clibu Notes has a tree that notes live in. The user creates this tree, can drag & drop nodes, rename them, change their icons, color etc. The tree is a YJS document so all changes resolve across all devices. We also use it for the rich text editor etc.
Feel free to try it for yourself. Feedback welcome and appreciated. clibu.com
Some good CRDT resources:
jakelazaroff.com
crdt.tech/
vlcn.io/blog/intro-to-crdts
medium.com/@amberovsky/crdt-confli...
And if you are interested in Local First development a new excellent podcast is:
localfirst.fm/
There are also several CRDT SQLite gaining traction at the moment.
ex. vlcn.io/docs/cr-sqlite/intro
HTH, Neville
check out pouchlite
I didn’t know that websockets are paid
lol
?
reminds me a lot of Meteor! You should defenitely check it out: meteor.com/
Its a great framework imo!
A lot of these can be solved with use of server side rendering along with lightweight javascript libraries like htmx and alpine.js.
which one of these problems can be solved with htmx and alpine?