DEV Community

Maxim Saplin
Maxim Saplin

Posted on • Edited on

C#, Dart, TypeScript , Python: side-by-side

String formating

Language Syntax Type Example Description
C# Composite Formatting string.Format("Hello {0}!", "World") Uses indexed placeholders within a format string.
Interpolation $"Hello {name}!" Allows embedding expressions inside string literals.
Dart String Interpolation 'Hello $name!' Uses the dollar sign ($) to interpolate the value of Dart expressions within strings.
Concatenation 'Hello ' + name + '!' Combines strings together using the + operator.
TypeScript Template Literals `Hello ${name}!` Uses backticks and ${} to interpolate expressions within strings.
Python Percent Formatting 'Hello %s!' % name Uses % as a placeholder for variables and provides a tuple of values.
str.format() 'Hello {}!'.format(name) Uses curly braces {} as placeholders and provides values via the format method.
f-Strings (Literal String Interpolation) f'Hello {name}!' Embeds expressions inside string literals using f-prefix and curly braces.

Each of these methods has its own advantages and use cases. For example, C#'s interpolated strings and Python's f-strings provide a very readable way to embed expressions in strings, while C#'s composite formatting is useful for more complex scenarios where you might want to reuse the same variable multiple times in a formatted string or apply specific formatting to values (like date or number formats).

It's important to note that these are not the only ways to format strings in these languages, but they are the most common and idiomatic methods

Ternary Conditional Operator

Language Syntax Example Equivalent If-Else Statement
C# var x = y == 2 ? 0 : 1; if (y == 2) { x = 0; } else { x = 1; }
Dart var x = y == 2 ? 0 : 1; if (y == 2) { x = 0; } else { x = 1; }
TypeScript let x = y == 2 ? 0 : 1; if (y == 2) { x = 0; } else { x = 1; }
Python x = 0 if y == 2 else 1 if y == 2: x = 0 else: x = 1

In Python, the ternary conditional operator is slightly different in syntax. It uses the if ... else keywords in a single line, rather than the ? and : symbols. The general form is x = true_value if condition else false_value.

In all these languages, the ternary conditional operator is used to make the code more concise and to reduce the need for a multi-line if-else statement when only a single value assignment is needed based on a condition.

Code Blocks

Language Code Block Definition Notes
C# Curly braces {} Curly braces are required to define the scope of code blocks for classes, methods, loops, and conditional statements. Indentation is a best practice for readability but is not enforced by the compiler.
Dart Curly braces {} Similar to C#, Dart uses curly braces to define the scope of code blocks. Indentation is recommended for readability but is not enforced by the language.
TypeScript Curly braces {} TypeScript, like JavaScript, uses curly braces to define the scope of functions, classes, loops, and conditional statements. Indentation is a matter of style and best practices, not a language requirement.
Python Indentation Python uses indentation to define code blocks. A consistent level of indentation is required to denote the scope of loops, conditional statements, functions, and classes. Curly braces are not used for this purpose.

C#, Dart, TypeScript: In these languages, a code block begins with an opening curly brace { and ends with a closing curly brace }. Everything within the braces is considered part of the same block. For example:

// C# example
if (condition)
{
    // This is a code block
    Console.WriteLine("Condition is true.");
}
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
// Dart example
if (condition) {
  // This is a code block
  print('Condition is true.');
}
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
// TypeScript example
if (condition) {
    // This is a code block
    console.log("Condition is true.");
}
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Python: Python uses indentation to define the beginning and end of a code block. The amount of indentation for each block is consistent, and typically four spaces are used per indentation level. For example:

# Python example
if condition:
    # This is a code block
    print("Condition is true.")
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Enforced by Language: The enforcement of curly braces or indentation is a syntactic requirement in these languages. In C#, Dart, and TypeScript, omitting curly braces for code blocks that require them will result in a compiler error. In Python, inconsistent indentation will lead to a syntax error.

Readability: While not enforced by the compiler or interpreter in C#, Dart, and TypeScript, indentation is still crucial for maintaining readable and maintainable code. It is considered a best practice to use consistent indentation, such as using spaces or tabs, to visually separate code blocks from the surrounding code.

Loops

For Loop

Language Syntax Example
C# for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) { /* ... */ }
Dart for (var i = 0; i < 10; i++) { /* ... */ }
TypeScript for (let i = 0; i < 10; i++) { /* ... */ }
Python for i in range(10): # ...

For-Each Loop

Language Syntax Example
C# foreach (var item in collection) { /* ... */ }
Dart for (var item in collection) { /* ... */ }
TypeScript for (let item of collection) { /* ... */ }
Python for item in collection: # ...

While Loop

Language Syntax Example
C# while (condition) { /* ... */ }
Dart while (condition) { /* ... */ }
TypeScript while (condition) { /* ... */ }
Python while condition: # ...

Do-While Loop

Language Syntax Example
C# do { /* ... */ } while (condition);
Dart do { /* ... */ } while (condition);
TypeScript do { /* ... */ } while (condition);
Python Python does not have a built-in do-while loop

Loop Control Statements

Language Break Example Continue Example
C# break; continue;
Dart break; continue;
TypeScript break; continue;
Python break continue

Notes on Loop Usage

C#, Dart, TypeScript: These languages share a similar C-style syntax for loops, including the traditional for loop with initialization, condition, and increment expressions. They also support for-each loops for iterating over collections, with slight differences in keyword usage (foreach in C# and for in Dart and TypeScript).

Python: Python's for loop is more like a for-each loop in C-style languages, iterating over items in a collection or sequence. Python uses the range() function to iterate over a sequence of numbers. Python does not have a traditional C-style for loop or a do-while loop.

Do-While Loop: Python does not have a built-in do-while loop construct. However, you can achieve similar behavior using a while loop with a condition that is always true initially, followed by a conditional break at the end of the loop body.

Loop Control Statements: The break statement is used to exit a loop prematurely, while the continue statement is used to skip the current iteration and proceed to the next iteration of the loop. These control statements are used similarly across all four languages.

Anonymous and Higher-Order Functions

Anonymous Functions (Lambdas)

Language Syntax Example
C# Func<int, int> square = x => x * x;
Dart var square = (int x) => x * x;
TypeScript const square = (x: number): number => x * x;
Python square = lambda x: x * x

Higher-Order Functions

Language Syntax Example (e.g., using map)
C# var squaredNumbers = numbers.Select(x => x * x);
Dart var squaredNumbers = numbers.map((x) => x * x);
TypeScript const squaredNumbers = numbers.map(x => x * x);
Python squared_numbers = map(lambda x: x * x, numbers)

Notes on Anonymous Functions and Higher-Order Functions

C# uses lambda expressions to create anonymous functions and has a variety of higher-order functions available through LINQ (Language Integrated Query), such as Select, Where, and Aggregate.

Dart supports arrow syntax for defining anonymous functions concisely. Higher-order functions like map, where, and reduce are commonly used on collections.

TypeScript, like Dart, uses arrow functions for concise anonymous function syntax. It also has higher-order functions on arrays similar to Dart and other JavaScript array methods.

Python uses the lambda keyword to define anonymous functions. It has built-in higher-order functions like map, filter, and reduce (the latter is found in the functools module).

Object-Oriented Programming

Feature C# Dart TypeScript Python
Class Definition class MyClass { } class MyClass { } class MyClass { } class MyClass:
Inheritance class Derived : Base { } class Derived extends Base class Derived extends Base class Derived(Base):
Interfaces interface IMyInterface { } class MyInterface { } interface IMyInterface { } class MyInterface:
Polymorphism Virtual/override methods Virtual methods with @override Methods can be overridden Defining methods in child classes
Encapsulation public/private/protected/internal/protected internal/private protected Public by default, private with _ public/private/protected Public by default, private with _
Abstraction Abstract classes/methods Abstract classes/methods Abstract classes/methods Not directly supported, use ABC module
Constructors MyClass() { } MyClass() { } constructor() { } def init(self):
Static Members static keyword static keyword static keyword @staticmethod decorator
Properties get; set; get and set keywords get and set keywords @property decorator
Method Overloading Supported Not supported Supported Not natively supported
Operator Overloading Supported Supported Not natively supported Supported
Multiple Inheritance Not supported Not supported Not supported Supported via Mixins
Access Modifiers Yes No (privacy by convention) Yes No (privacy by convention)

Here are some key points about OOP in each language:

C#: C# is a statically typed language with a rich set of OOP features. It supports most of the classical OOP concepts, including interfaces, abstract classes, encapsulation with access modifiers, and polymorphism through virtual and override methods. C# does not support multiple inheritance for classes, but it allows a class to implement multiple interfaces.

Dart: Dart is an object-oriented language that supports classes and interface-like behavior using abstract classes. Unlike C#, Dart does not have interfaces as a separate construct; instead, every class implicitly defines an interface. Dart does not support method overloading but does support operator overloading. It uses a single underscore to denote private members.

TypeScript: TypeScript is a superset of JavaScript that adds static typing and OOP features. It supports classes, interfaces, and inheritance. TypeScript's OOP features are similar to those of C#, but since it compiles down to JavaScript, which is a prototype-based language, some features like operator overloading are not natively supported.

Python: Python is a dynamically typed language that supports OOP. It allows for multiple inheritance and uses a special module called abc (Abstract Base Classes) to create abstract classes and methods. Python does not have built-in access modifiers, but it follows a naming convention using underscores to indicate the intended level of privacy. Method overloading is not natively supported, but operator overloading is.

Top comments (10)

Collapse
 
Sloan, the sloth mascot
Comment deleted
Collapse
 
maximsaplin profile image
Maxim Saplin • Edited

Tell about those horrible newlines to 100% of C# code produced by MS: github.com/dotnet/efcore/blob/main...

Frankly I don't understand why something that subjective (e.g. tabs vs spaces, newline or same line starting bracket) can be presented as something definitive and solely right...

Besides, I don't understand the python sample you gave, it is invalid syntax and won't run...

Collapse
 
webjose profile image
José Pablo Ramírez Vargas

The trend you mention has been in place for decades, ever since the inception of C# and is the de-facto standard for this language. That's not changing any time soon.

Collapse
 
webjose profile image
Info Comment hidden by post author - thread only accessible via permalink
José Pablo Ramírez Vargas • Edited

Guidelines for AI-assisted articles

It would also be nice to not artificially upvote articles. I'll never understand this practice.

Collapse
 
maximsaplin profile image
Maxim Saplin • Edited

"we care most that the author of the post is able to stand by the information they are sharing. " - go check my GitHub, those 4 languages are the ones I code a lot

It would also be nice to leave comments only after reading the article. I'll never understand this practice.

Collapse
 
webjose profile image
Info Comment hidden by post author - thread only accessible via permalink
José Pablo Ramírez Vargas

Why would it be relevant that you code a lot in those 4 languages? Does it change the fact that the guidelines for AI-assisted articles was not followed? How does one connect the dots here?

Also, why hide my comment?

 
maximsaplin profile image
Info Comment hidden by post author - thread only accessible via permalink
Maxim Saplin

I don't like troll-like comments with false assumptions stated as facts

Collapse
 
webjose profile image
José Pablo Ramírez Vargas

What? No comeback? Just hide my comments. Follow the guidelines. It is not forbidden to use AI, you just need to disclose the fact.

Collapse
 
mjamesharmon profile image
MJ Harmon • Edited

Thank you for your write-up. One note on your OOP section – C# also has internal as a modifier for encapsulation.

Collapse
 
maximsaplin profile image
Maxim Saplin

Good point, updated! There're also protected internal and private protected access modifiers (but they are used less often).

Some comments have been hidden by the post's author - find out more