DEV Community

Ilia Ivanov
Ilia Ivanov

Posted on

I read the cold email law of 30 countries. Writing to info@ needs consent in 10 of them

Last week I almost sent cold emails to small shops in Spain. Then I read the Spanish law and found out a first marketing email there needs consent, even when you write to a company. Vendor blogs said different things, so I went to the source: the law text or the regulator's own guidance, one country at a time.

I am at 30 countries now. Here is what they say about the first unsolicited marketing email to a business. This is a research summary, not legal advice.

Writing to a generic company address (info@company)

No consent needed (14): United States, United Kingdom, France, Belgium, Ireland, Sweden, Norway, Finland, Portugal, Estonia, Latvia, Luxembourg, Slovenia, Croatia.

Allowed with conditions (5): Canada, Australia, Netherlands, Slovakia, Bulgaria.

Consent first (10): Germany, Spain, Italy, Denmark, Austria, Poland, Switzerland, Czech Republic, Malta, Greece.

Not verified yet (1): Cyprus. The consent rule there covers only natural persons, and companies fall under a separate 2005 order I have not been able to read.

Writing to a named person (jane.doe@company)

This is where it gets strict. Plainly allowed without consent in only 4: the US, the UK, France (if the offer relates to the person's job) and Sweden. In several countries the law protects "natural persons" and says nothing clear about an employee's work address, so for 7 countries I marked it as not verified instead of guessing.

Things that surprised me

  • Belgium treats info@ and jane@ differently. A royal decree lifts the consent rule for legal persons only when the address is impersonal.
  • Slovakia has an unusual exception: no consent is needed when you write to contact details that a company or sole trader has published itself (section 116(15) of the Electronic Communications Act).
  • Slovenia says almost the same thing about named people: you can use a person's address if the company published it as its own contact address (article 226(6) of ZEKom-2).
  • Bulgaria keeps an official opt-out register for companies. You can email a company unless its address is in the register, and the email has to be recognisable as unsolicited as soon as it arrives.
  • Greece and Malta protect companies exactly like individuals. Consent first, for everyone.
  • The US is the opposite: CAN-SPAM is an opt-out law and covers B2B email, but every email needs a postal address and a working way to opt out.

What every country asks for, even where consent is not needed

Say who you are, and give a working way to stop. Most of the countries above put that in the law text itself.

The data

Every country has its own page with the verdict for each kind of address, what the email must contain, and links to the law or the regulator. Each page shows the date I checked it.

https://phazww.github.io/can-i-cold-email/

If you know one of these laws better than I do and see a mistake, tell me in the comments and I will fix it and credit you. The next countries I want to add are Lithuania, Hungary and Romania. Their official law portals were not reachable from where I am, so if you have a link to the current text, that helps too.

Top comments (2)

Collapse
 
kevin_hall profile image
Kevin Hall •

This is the most useful version of this table I have seen, because it splits by address type rather than by country alone. One consequence for whoever builds the list, not only for whoever writes the email: the address type has to be a column, not something discovered at send time. Three values cover your findings: an impersonal company address, a named person's work address, and a personal mailbox. The last one is the easy mistake. Enrichment tools label an address as work or personal, and a business owner's gmail is a natural person's address in every one of your 30 jurisdictions, so the B2B exemptions never apply to it even when the person is the company.

The Slovakia and Slovenia exceptions add a fourth column, where the address came from: an address the company published itself is a different legal object from one a vendor found. With those two columns on the list, the per-country rule becomes a filter you run before the send instead of a judgment call per email.

Collapse
 
phaz profile image
Ilia Ivanov •

Thank you, that's a sharp way to put it: address type and address source as columns, then the rule becomes a filter. The list checker on the site already guesses the first column (info@ vs named vs gmail) from the address itself, and your comment made me think the source column is worth adding. One nuance on the gmail point: Slovakia's exemption also covers published contacts of sole traders, and Bulgaria's consent rule only protects people acting outside their business, so a sole trader's published gmail can fall outside it there. Everywhere else in the table, yes, it counts as a person.