DEV Community

w4ffl35
w4ffl35

Posted on Edited on Originally published at joecurlee.com

Artificial Technology Scarcity and the End of First Amendment Rights on the Internet

We are watching the death of personal technology, the First Amendment, and the internet in one fell swoop.

Elon Musk has already shown us how much control one person can exercise over online speech by purchasing Twitter and reshaping the platform. “Freedom of speech, not freedom of reach”—the cry of any true statist. You can speak, but the owner decides whether anyone hears you. 1

The federal government strongly backs AI companies. OpenAI put former NSA director Paul Nakasone on its board. xAI announced a military partnership. Anthropic supplied Claude for military and intelligence work before its confrontation with the Pentagon. The companies inviting us to pour our private lives into a chat window have built businesses around the institutions we should most want to keep out of it. 2

Your conversations are monitored and flagged on these platforms. OpenAI says it sends flagged conversations through human review and notifies law enforcement when it identifies an imminent and credible risk of harm to others. Anthropic’s published policy permits government disclosures under valid legal process and in emergencies involving imminent physical harm or death. A private company’s judgment can put your conversation in government hands. 3

Washington is helping build this industry while working to push aside state restrictions. We are told to move faster in the name of national security and winning the AI race. Think about the reaction to 9/11 and the rush into a war that lasted 20 years. When someone insists there is no time to question where they are taking you, question it.

Both parties are backing this buildout. I see us being pushed toward artificial technological scarcity: a future in which owning the means to compute becomes harder, renting access becomes normal, and speaking online depends on clearing somebody else’s checks. To me, this frenzy has all the hallmarks of a psychological operation.

I wrote the original introduction and directed the research using Codex GPT-6.1 Sol. The original research, outline and article draft were produced with AI assistance.

Computing on Their Terms

Sam Altman has explained exactly what bothers him about people running AI locally. In his late-October Cheeky Pint interview, he called allocating scarce DRAM to personal computers used only a small fraction of the time “quite terrible.” He preferred “maximum utilization in the cloud.” In his calculation, memory serves the world better inside a data center than inside your computer. 4

I bought my computer to run software when I choose, keep my work private, and continue using it when a company changes its prices or decides it no longer wants my business. Sam Altman’s utilization figures have nothing to say about the value of that independence. Memory sitting idle on my desk is still mine to use.

OpenAI has the purchasing power to help shape the market behind that argument. Its October 2025 announcement with Samsung and SK described plans targeting 900,000 DRAM wafer starts per month. On October 31, Altman met about 50 Samsung executives in Yongin to discuss AI strategy, according to Samsung’s account reported by Yonhap. That is the scale at which it negotiates for the hardware the rest of us also need. 5

Micron announced its exit from the Crucial consumer business in December 2025, explicitly tying the decision to AI demand and serving larger strategic customers. It set February 2026 as the end of consumer-channel shipments. TrendForce’s fourth-quarter research says suppliers are still prioritizing advanced capacity for server products, forecasts conventional DRAM contract prices rising another 10–15%, and warns that PC memory supply could shrink in 2027 as more capacity moves to servers. Consumers are being pushed down the list of priorities, and the manufacturers are telling us why. 6

Factories take time to build. Production limits are real. So are the decisions about which customers get served and which businesses get abandoned. Calling the result a shortage does not put those decisions beyond criticism. When the industry channels capacity toward enormous buyers and then offers everyone else a subscription, scarcity becomes a way to make dependency profitable.

Owning high-end consumer hardware is already expensive. Nvidia launched the RTX 4090 at $1,599 and the RTX 5090 at $1,999. The starting price of admission to its flagship consumer tier rose by $400 between generations, before retailer markups. 7

Its software makes leaving expensive, too. France’s competition authority identified the proprietary CUDA ecosystem among the barriers facing generative-AI competitors. Software built around one vendor’s hardware takes work to move. A competing chip does little for your independence if your software keeps you tied to the incumbent. 8

The FTC’s January 2025 report on Microsoft–OpenAI, Amazon–Anthropic and Alphabet–Anthropic documented cloud-spending commitments, control and exclusivity rights, and switching costs. These arrangements have since changed: in April 2026, OpenAI and Microsoft announced that OpenAI could serve all its products across any cloud provider and that Microsoft’s model license would become non-exclusive. Microsoft remained its primary cloud partner and a major shareholder, with OpenAI’s revenue-share payments continuing through 2030, subject to a cap. The restrictions are negotiable. Regulators should demand to know which ones remain and what it costs a smaller rival to escape them. 9

Antitrust enforcement should go straight at these contracts. Investigate the exclusive terms, the restrictions on switching providers, and acquisitions that eliminate independent competition. Enforce the Sherman Act against anticompetitive restraints and monopolization, and the Clayton Act against acquisitions that substantially threaten competition. The public should not have to wait until every affordable alternative has disappeared before regulators act. 10

Washington is helping finance the buildout. Biden’s January 2025 infrastructure initiative proposed federal sites for private AI development. Trump’s July 2025 order directed an initiative for financial support that could include loans, guarantees, grants, tax incentives and purchase commitments. Routes to qualification included projects committing at least $500 million or adding more than 100 megawatts. Across administrations, federal support has been organized around enormous infrastructure projects. 11

The December 2025 order directed a federal task force to challenge state AI laws, threatened funding pressure against certain state restrictions, and called for a national framework preempting conflicting laws. Attorney General Pam Bondi established the task force on January 9, 2026. On April 24, DOJ moved to intervene in xAI’s lawsuit against Colorado’s AI antidiscrimination law. Washington is putting federal lawyers behind an AI company’s attack on state regulation. The public deserves a government willing to confront this industry, not one that treats its objections as marching orders. 12

If public money is going into computing infrastructure, the public should gain independence from it. Universities, small businesses and individual developers need durable access they can use without becoming permanent customers of a handful of corporations. A temporary allocation of cloud credits cannot substitute for an independent computing sector.

The military relationships make that independence more urgent. OpenAI says its Pentagon agreement prohibits domestic surveillance of U.S. persons and that NSA use would require a separate agreement. Those commitments should be enforceable and independently checked. My privacy should also survive a future contract change. A corporate promise is a poor substitute for keeping my work on hardware I control. 13

Anthropic refused to remove its restrictions on mass domestic surveillance and fully autonomous weapons, and the administration branded it a supply-chain risk. On August 27, 2026, Judge Rita Lin ruled that the government had retaliated against Anthropic’s protected speech and denied it due process; she rejected the Pentagon’s designation under 10 U.S.C. § 3252 and the broader effort to force other contractors to cut ties. On September 25, a divided D.C. Circuit upheld a separate procurement exclusion under the Federal Acquisition Supply Chain Security Act, accepting the Pentagon’s argument that Anthropic’s embedded use restrictions could interfere with military operations. Those decisions address different government actions under different statutes. 14

Anthropic sought rehearing, and on October 15 the appeals court ordered the government to respond. The government has already used its purchasing power to punish a supplier that refused to abandon limits on surveillance and weapons. Anthropic was right to resist. I do not want the privacy of millions of people hanging on whether one company can afford to hold its ground against the Pentagon. Hardware we own, software we can run ourselves, and enforceable limits on government surveillance matter more than any executive’s promise to stand firm. 14

Meanwhile, the consumer services are building records of what people say to them. OpenAI describes automated analysis, human assessment of flagged conversations and law-enforcement referrals in qualifying cases. Anthropic says it can retain flagged inputs and outputs for up to two years and trust-and-safety classification scores for up to seven. A company’s judgment about your conversation can outlast the conversation itself. 3 15

There are rules governing disclosure: legal process, emergency exceptions, and separate reporting obligations for specified child-sexual-exploitation offenses. The reporting statute expressly says it does not require providers to monitor or search users’ communications. Companies should explain which disclosures the law compels, which it permits, and which monitoring practices they choose themselves. Users deserve that answer before their thoughts become somebody else’s retained records. 16

The intelligence value of commercial information is already understood inside government. ODNI’s declassified advisory report describes the sensitivity of commercially available data, the privacy risks of aggregation, and the possibility of identifying people in supposedly anonymous information. The intelligence community now has a formal policy framework for acquiring and handling that information; ODNI’s first biennial public report was declassified in September 2026. The government is organizing access to the commercial data economy. Putting more of our lives into that economy creates more information to seek, compel or acquire. Minimize collection and retention at the source. 17

Age-verification laws introduce another condition on access. Bluesky initially blocked Mississippi because of the compliance burden, then reopened access for adults completing age assurance while continuing to exclude minors. Mississippi users first lost the service entirely and then had to complete a check to get back in. The compliance burden fell on a smaller competitor and the people trying to use it. 18

Courts are allowing significant restrictions. In October 2026, the Eleventh Circuit removed the preliminary injunction against Florida’s restrictions on accounts for children under 14 and on accounts for 14- and 15-year-olds without parental consent, reversing in part, vacating in part and remanding the case. In 2025, the Supreme Court upheld Texas’s age-verification requirement for covered commercial sites distributing sexual material obscene to minors. These decisions concern different laws and different speech, but both belong in the argument over how much of the internet should require proof of eligibility to enter. 19

The access checks are spreading. On October 29, 2026, Ofcom identified photo-ID matching, digital IDs, banking checks and facial age estimation as methods capable of supporting the UK’s announced under-16 social-media ban, with detailed rules still to come and implementation expected in 2027. Every imposed check adds a system that can reject people, a company entrusted with information, and a compliance cost a small service must absorb. Protecting children does not relieve lawmakers of the obligation to justify those burdens. I reject the idea that ordinary participation online should gradually become something we have to qualify for. 20

We are being trained to accept dependency in the rest of our technology, too. GeForce NOW gives Performance and Ultimate subscribers 100 monthly hours of premium playtime, with paid extensions and limited rollover. Sony requires an internet connection to pair the separately sold PS5 Pro disc drive during setup. You can buy the console and the drive and still have to contact Sony to finish pairing them. 21

Independent publishing depends on being able to operate without a narrow set of institutions granting permission. Broadcasting’s history shows how scarcity and access rules can become entangled. In Reno v. ACLU, the Supreme Court distinguished the internet from broadcasting when striking down online-indecency restrictions. Preserving the internet’s capacity for independent publishing requires defending the infrastructure that makes it possible. 22

Private platforms have editorial rights of their own. That makes the ability to leave them essential. Government officials also face a constitutional limit: they cannot coerce private intermediaries into suppressing disfavored advocacy. NRA v. Vullo reaffirmed that principle. A government should not be able to accomplish through pressure on a provider what the Constitution forbids it to impose directly. 23

Anonymous political speech also has constitutional protection. McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission struck down an identification requirement for campaign literature. Anonymity lets people criticize power without first presenting their identity to it. I want that freedom to remain practical on the internet. 24

The First Amendment can remain on paper while the means to exercise it move out of reach. Price people out of owning useful hardware, make independent services expensive to operate, and place more checks between a person and an audience. The result is an internet in which formal rights coexist with a shrinking ability to act on them.

Enforce competition law. Demand interoperable software and affordable consumer hardware. Put public computing investment to work building independent capacity. Challenge access restrictions that burden speech, limit data retention and government access, and protect encryption and anonymous participation.

Above all, refuse the demand to surrender these things because an executive says the race is urgent. The people asking us to accept permanent dependence are the people who stand to profit from it. Their timetable does not outrank our freedom.

I want affordable local computing, strong encryption, anonymous participation, and continued offline access to purchased media.

I want a computer I control and an internet I can use without asking a corporation or the state for permission.

Sources

  1. Twitter’s published enforcement policy.
  2. OpenAI’s appointment of Paul Nakasone; xAI’s military partnership announcement; Dario Amodei’s statement on military and intelligence deployments and government pressure.
  3. OpenAI’s monitoring and law-enforcement referral policy; Anthropic’s government-request policy.
  4. Cheeky Pint interview transcript, local inference discussion around minute 29.
  5. OpenAI’s Samsung and SK memory partnership announcement; Yonhap’s October 31, 2026 report on Samsung’s meeting with Sam Altman.
  6. Micron’s announcement that it would exit the Crucial consumer business; TrendForce’s September 30, 2026 memory-market research.
  7. Nvidia’s RTX 4090 launch announcement; Nvidia’s RTX 5090 launch announcement.
  8. French competition authority’s generative-AI report, paragraphs 124–130.
  9. FTC findings on AI and cloud-provider partnerships; Microsoft–OpenAI amended partnership, April 27, 2026.
  10. DOJ’s explanation of the antitrust laws; Clayton Act Section 7, 15 U.S.C. § 18.
  11. Biden’s January 14, 2025 AI infrastructure statement; Trump’s July 2025 data-center executive order.
  12. Executive Order 14365, particularly Sections 3, 5 and 8; DOJ memorandum establishing the AI Litigation Task Force, January 9, 2026; DOJ’s April 24, 2026 motion to intervene in xAI’s Colorado lawsuit.
  13. OpenAI’s Pentagon agreement and March 2, 2026 update.
  14. Judge Lin’s summary-judgment order, August 27, 2026; D.C. Circuit opinion and dissent, September 25, 2026; D.C. Circuit order directing a response to the rehearing petition, October 15, 2026.
  15. Anthropic’s consumer data-retention policy.
  16. Stored Communications Act disclosure provisions, 18 U.S.C. § 2702; Compelled disclosure, 18 U.S.C. § 2703; Mandatory reporting and the absence of a monitoring mandate, 18 U.S.C. § 2258A.
  17. Declassified ODNI advisory report on commercially available information; ODNI’s commercially available information framework and September 2026 report.
  18. Bluesky’s age-assurance explanation and Mississippi updates.
  19. Florida Statutes § 501.1736; Eleventh Circuit opinion of October 14, 2026; Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, June 27, 2025.
  20. Ofcom’s explanation of age-check methods; Ofcom’s October 29, 2026 assessment of age checks for the announced UK social-media ban.
  21. Nvidia’s GeForce NOW FAQ, monthly playtime limits; Sony’s PS5 Pro page, disc-drive pairing requirement.
  22. Red Lion Broadcasting Co. v. FCC; FCC v. Pacifica Foundation; Reno v. ACLU; Communications Act censorship limitation, 47 U.S.C. § 326.
  23. Moody v. NetChoice; NRA v. Vullo.
  24. McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission.

Top comments (0)