DEV Community

octave Nkurunziza
octave Nkurunziza

Posted on Originally published at blog.hubfly.space

Plausible vs Fathom vs Umami: which one costs less in 2026?

You want privacy-friendly analytics without a cookie banner, and it's down to Plausible vs Fathom vs Umami. All three count pageviews without cookies. The real difference is the bill: how each one counts your traffic, what happens when you go over, and whether running it yourself is cheaper. This guide puts all three on one price table at 10k, 100k, 1M and 10M monthly pageviews, then shows what the self-hosted versions cost on a real container platform.

Short answer: under 100k pageviews, Umami Cloud's free plan is hard to beat. Around 1M, Umami Cloud Pro ($20) is the cheapest hosted option. If you want to run it yourself, Umami is the light one; Plausible Community Edition needs ClickHouse and about three times the resources.

Try it on Hubfly space

Plausible vs Fathom vs Umami: the price table

All prices are monthly billing in USD, read from each official pricing page on 9 November 2026. Yearly billing is cheaper on Plausible and Fathom (both give two months free).

Monthly pageviews Plausible Starter (1 site) Fathom Umami Cloud Umami self-hosted on Hubfly space
10k $9 $15 (smallest plan) $0 (Hobby) from $4.66 (starter size)
100k $19 $15 $0 (Hobby, 100k events cap) from $4.66 (starter size)
1M $69 $60 $20 (Pro) from $4.66 (starter size)
2M $89 $100 $50 (Pro + overage) size up
10M $169 $200 $200 (Business) size up

The self-hosted price is the starting size; give it more RAM and disk as traffic grows.

A few things the table hides:

  • Plausible's price depends on the plan, not just traffic. Starter covers one site. For up to 3 sites and team members you need Growth ($29 at 100k, $104 at 1M). Funnels, revenue and the Stats API are on Business ($39 at 100k, $139 at 1M).
  • Fathom includes 50 sites on every plan and has no free plan. Its high-traffic plans start at $140 for 5M and go to $470 for 25M.
  • Umami Cloud's Hobby plan is one website with 6 months of data. Pro covers up to 20 websites and 2 years; Business adds unlimited sites and 5 years.

How each one counts your traffic

This is where the cheap option can turn expensive.

Plausible bills on pageviews plus custom events across all sites in a team. Custom events include outbound link clicks, file downloads, form submissions and 404 tracking (Plausible docs). Turn on outbound-link tracking on a link-heavy site and your billable total can jump.

Fathom works the same way: pageviews and custom events share one allowance across all your sites (Fathom pricing).

Umami Cloud counts pageviews, custom events, and every stored event property as one event each (Umami pricing FAQ). That last part catches people.

Here's a worked example. A site has 70,000 pageviews and 10,000 signup-button clicks a month. Each click is tracked with two properties (plan and source).

  • Plausible and Fathom count 70,000 + 10,000 = 80,000.
  • Umami Cloud counts 70,000 + 10,000 + (10,000 × 2) = 100,000 events.

That's right at the Hobby cap. One more property and you're on Pro at $20. If you track events with properties, estimate Umami Cloud on events, not pageviews.

What happens when you go over

All three are kinder about traffic spikes than most SaaS tools, but in different ways.

  • Plausible: one month over your tier needs no action. Two months in a row and you're asked to upgrade; if you don't within a week, the dashboard locks. Stats keep being collected while it's locked (Plausible billing FAQ).
  • Fathom: going over doesn't change your subscription automatically. They email you, and if usage stays high, dashboard and API access lock. Collection doesn't stop (Fathom limits).
  • Umami Cloud: no lock. Extra events are billed at $0.00003 each on Pro and $0.00002 on Business, and collection is never interrupted (Umami pricing).

Umami's model means a viral month costs money instead of locking your dashboard. On Pro, 2M events is $20 + 1,000,000 × $0.00003 = $50.

The Pro-to-Business crossover is 7M events. Pro costs $20 + (events − 1M) × $0.00003. That equals Business's $200 when the overage is $180, which is 6M extra events, or 7M in total. Above 7M events a month, switch to Business; at 10M, Pro would be $290.

Where each one wins

Be clear-eyed here. None of these is the best pick for everyone.

Pick Plausible if you want a managed service with serious bot filtering and EU hosting. Plausible Cloud excludes around 32,000 data center IP ranges by default and keeps all visitor data on EU-owned infrastructure in Germany (Plausible CE vs Cloud). For one site, Starter is also the cheapest of the paid options at 10k and at 10M pageviews on monthly billing. The 30-day trial needs no card.

Pick Fathom if you run many small sites. 50 sites are included even on the $15 plan, so an agency with 30 client sites pays one bill. It also wins at 100k–1M if you'd otherwise need Plausible Growth for multiple sites. The trial is 7 days and needs a card.

Pick Umami Cloud if you're under 100k events on one site (free), or around 1M events where Pro at $20 is a third of the others. Just count your event properties.

Pick self-hosted Umami if you want a flat bill, full data ownership and you're fine running a small app and its database yourself. Umami is open source under the MIT license (GitHub).

What self-hosting actually costs

"Self-host it for free" is only half true. The software is free; the server isn't. Here are the two open-source options running on Hubfly space, priced from its public rates: $0.004 per vCPU-hour, $0.002 per GB-hour of RAM and $0.00001536 per GB-hour of storage, with 730 hours in a month.

Umami: about $4.66 a month

Umami needs two services: the Umami app (the postgresql-latest image, Next.js 16) and PostgreSQL 15. Hubfly space has an Umami preset in the Stack Composer. At its defaults (1 vCPU and 1 GB RAM per service) the estimate is $8.98 a month. Umami doesn't need that much to start, so drop both services to 0.5 vCPU and 512 MB.

Umami stack in the Hubfly space Stack Composer at 0.5 vCPU and 512 MB per service, estimate $4.60 a month

The math per service:

  • CPU: 0.5 × $0.004 × 730 = $1.46
  • RAM: 0.5 GB × $0.002 × 730 = $0.73
  • Container disk: 5 GB × $0.00001536 × 730 = $0.06
  • Per service: $2.25

Two services come to $4.49. The 10 GB database volume adds $0.11 at the Standard storage rate (10 × $0.00001536 × 730), so the composer shows $4.60. After deploying, the project's budget panel projected $4.66 a month.

Once running, the app sat at about 40% of its 512 MB (roughly 210 MB) and Postgres at about 12% (roughly 60 MB), with plenty of headroom on both.

Umami and Postgres running on Hubfly space: Umami at about 40% of 512 MB RAM, Postgres at about 12%

Deploying the stack took 42 seconds, and Umami applied its 26 database migrations on first boot.

Plausible Community Edition: about $13.53 a month, and it won't start as-is

Plausible CE needs three services: the Plausible app, PostgreSQL for settings and users, and ClickHouse for the event data. Plausible's own guide (CE v3.2.1) recommends at least 2 GB of RAM in total (plausible/community-edition).

The Hubfly space preset (Plausible, ClickHouse and PostgreSQL 16) gives each service 1 vCPU and 1 GB:

  • 3 × (1 × $0.004 + 1 × $0.002) × 730 = $13.14 compute
  • 15 GB of container disk: $0.17
  • Two 10 GB volumes: $0.22
  • Total: $13.53 a month

ClickHouse is the hungry one. With no data in it at all, it used about 62% of its 1 GB.

Plausible CE stack: ClickHouse at about 62% of 1 GB RAM while empty, Postgres at 3%

So Plausible CE costs about three times as much to run as Umami at the starting size, before any traffic arrives.

Also note the trade-offs Plausible lists for CE: no marketing funnels, user journeys, ecommerce revenue goals or SSO; simpler bot filtering; and releases about twice a year (Plausible CE vs Cloud).

The work you take on

The price above is only the server. Self-hosting also means:

  • Upgrades and security fixes. You apply them; nobody does it for you.
  • Backups. Your analytics live in that Postgres (or ClickHouse) volume. Set a backup up on day one; see volumes.
  • Bot filtering. A self-hosted instance only sees its own traffic, so it can't learn from other sites.
  • Growth. At millions of pageviews a month, plan for more RAM and a bigger volume. Each extra GB of disk costs about $0.011 a month at the Standard rate, so storage stays cheap; RAM is what grows the bill.

If that list sounds like a chore, a hosted plan is the honest answer.

What can go wrong

Plausible CE crash-loops on first start. The logs fill with:

** (RuntimeError) BASE_URL configuration option is required.
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Plausible CE refuses to boot without BASE_URL. Its setup guide lists BASE_URL (your dashboard's public address, such as https://stats.your-domain.com) and SECRET_KEY_BASE (at least 64 bytes, for example from openssl rand -base64 48) as required. The preset sets neither, so add both to the plausible service before you deploy.

Umami logs "Can't reach database server" on the first boot. The app can start before Postgres is accepting connections. Umami retries, and the next attempt applies the migrations and starts normally. If it keeps failing, check that DATABASE_URL points at the database service's name and port 5432.

You can still log in with admin / umami. Umami creates that default account on first setup (Umami install docs). Change the password the moment you first log in, and set a strong database password and an APP_SECRET of your own before you deploy (the preset ships sample values for both).

Your Umami Cloud bill is higher than your pageviews. Each stored event property counts as an event. Cut properties you never filter by, or move to Pro before you hit the Hobby cap.

Your Plausible or Fathom dashboard locks. That's the overage rule, not an outage. Data is still being collected; upgrade (Plausible pro-rates the change) or wait for traffic to fall back within your tier.

FAQ

Is Plausible cheaper than Fathom?

At 10k pageviews, yes ($9 vs $15). At 100k and 1M, Fathom is cheaper ($15 vs $19, $60 vs $69) on monthly billing. At 10M, Plausible Starter is cheaper ($169 vs $200). If you have more than one site, compare Fathom against Plausible Growth, not Starter.

Is Umami really free?

The software is free and MIT-licensed if you host it yourself; you pay only for the server. Umami Cloud also has a free Hobby plan for one website and up to 100k events a month, with 6 months of data retention.

Do I need a cookie banner with Plausible, Fathom or Umami?

All three say their cookieless tracking doesn't need one. You're still responsible for your own privacy policy and local rules, so read each vendor's privacy page before you remove a banner.

How much RAM does self-hosted Umami need?

A fresh install idled at about 210 MB for the app and about 60 MB for Postgres, so 512 MB per service is a comfortable starting size. Give it more as your data and traffic grow.

Can I self-host Plausible on a small server?

Plausible recommends at least 2 GB of RAM for the whole stack, because ClickHouse alone takes a big share. An empty ClickHouse used about 630 MB. A 1 GB server for all three services is asking for out-of-memory crashes.

Which one is best for a small blog?

If you have one site under 100k pageviews, Umami Cloud's free plan. If you want a flat bill and own your data, self-hosted Umami for about $4.66 a month.

Go further on Hubfly space

  • Put your dashboard on your own domain. Attach stats.your-domain.com to the Umami container with HTTPS and no custom-domain fee. See custom domains.
  • Cap the bill. Set a monthly budget cap on the project so a runaway month can't surprise you. See billing.
  • Keep the database safe. Learn how project volumes and storage classes work before your analytics data grows. See volumes.

Related reading: How to self host Umami analytics with Postgres · Cookieless analytics without a consent banner: how it works · Usage-based vs fixed pricing for hosting

New accounts on Hubfly space make a one-time $5 deposit before creating resources. It's prepaid credit, not a fee, and it covers about a month of the Umami stack above.

Try it on Hubfly space


By Octave · drafted with AI, tested on Hubfly · Last updated 9 November 2026

Top comments (0)