The question comes up in almost every sourcing thread: how many shops should I quote before I pick one?
Most answers are folklore — "always three," "at least five," "get seven and average them." None of those survive contact with what actually happens when you send an RFQ.
Here's what the numbers look like.
The first quote is an anchor, not information
Whatever the first shop comes back with becomes your reference point. If it's $18 and the market is $12, every subsequent quote looks cheap by comparison and you'll accept $14 thinking you did well.
This is a real effect and it's well documented in procurement. The practical countermeasure is to send all RFQs on the same day, and not to open any response until you've collected all of them. Sounds bureaucratic; it changes outcomes.
The spread between shops is mostly not about price
When three shops quote $12, $14, and $31 for the same drawing, the $31 is rarely "expensive." Usually one of four things happened:
- They read the drawing differently. One shop assumed ±0.05 on the bore, another read it as ±0.005 because the note was ambiguous.
- They included something the others didn't. Material cert, FAI report, surface treatment, packing.
- They don't want the job. A shop with full 5-axis capacity quoting a 50-piece turning job is signaling.
- They made an error. Setup time estimated wrong, material price stale.
Only one of those four is a price difference. The other three are information problems, and more quotes won't fix them — a better RFQ will.
A 3× spread is a red flag on your RFQ, not on the market.
Diminishing returns kick in around four
The useful information from quotes is the distribution. With two quotes you have a range but no idea where the median sits. With three you can see if one is an outlier. With four you can usually tell whether the low one is credible or just optimistic.
By the fifth quote, you're mostly learning the same thing again. The fifth and sixth responses move your expected value by a few percent while costing you another week of clarification emails.
Four is the point where the marginal quote stops changing the decision.
The real cost is clarification, not the quotes themselves
Every shop asks some version of the same five questions:
- What material, and is the cert required?
- What quantity, and is that one lot or scheduled releases?
- Which dimensions are critical?
- What surface finish / treatment?
- Which Incoterm, and which port?
If you answer those five in the RFQ package, response time drops from a week to two days and the quotes become comparable. If you don't, you'll spend that week answering the same email four times, and the quotes you get back won't be for the same scope.
So the cheapest thing you can do is write the RFQ properly, not send it to more people.
What a complete RFQ package contains
For a machined part, this is the baseline:
| Item | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| 2D drawing with GD&T | The 3D model doesn't carry tolerance intent |
| STEP file | Geometry, for CAM and stock calculation |
| Material + condition | 6061-T6 ≠ 6061-T651 for stress and price |
| Quantity + lot structure | 100 in one lot ≠ 4 × 25 |
| Critical dimensions marked | Saves the shop guessing which features to control |
| Surface treatment spec | Anodize type/color/thickness, or "none" |
| Inspection requirement | FAI, sampling, CMM report, or none |
| Incoterm + destination | EXW Shenzhen vs DDP Chicago is a 30% swing |
| Target date | Design freeze vs production launch changes urgency |
Nine lines. Fills one email. Turns four incomparable quotes into four comparable ones.
When to quote more than four
Three legitimate cases:
Non-standard material. If you need Inconel 718 or a specific PEEK grade, most shops don't stock it, and their quotes include different lead times from different distributors. Four quotes on the material alone may not be enough.
A process you can't evaluate. Thread rolling, EDM, vacuum brazing, passivation — if you don't know what the process should cost, more data points help you build a range.
A first order with a new supplier. For the first job with a shop you haven't used, quoting a second shop as a benchmark is cheap insurance. Not because you'll switch, but because you'll know if the price drifts on the second PO.
When to quote fewer
- Repeat part, same shop, material price stable: one quote, maybe a refresh every six months.
- Simple parts with a published price structure (laser cutting, waterjet): two.
- Urgent repair or one-off fixture: whoever can start today.
The decision rule that actually works
Quote four. Send the same complete package to all four on the same day. Don't open responses until all four are in. Then look at the spread:
- Under 15% spread: pick on lead time and communication, not price. The market has spoken.
- 15–50% spread: compare scope line by line. Someone left something out.
- Over 100% spread: your RFQ was ambiguous. Rewrite it and re-send to the same four.
Notice that in none of these branches does the answer become "get more quotes."
We quote from a complete package in 1–2 business days, tolerances to ±0.005 mm, one piece minimum. chxmetal.com has the RFQ checklist we use on our side.
Related:
Top comments (1)
A useful add-on is a one-page bid tab with a “basis/assumptions” column alongside price: material grade and condition, lot structure, inspection, finish, packaging, shipping term, and exclusions. Mark each item “included,” “extra,” or “unclear,” then send the same clarification question to any shop with an unclear cell before ranking bids. It prevents a low headline quote from winning just because the missing work is hiding in an email thread. Save the answered tab as the baseline for the next PO; it makes price drift much easier to spot.