Most bad first orders are not machining failures. They are drawing handoffs where both sides assumed something the other never wrote down. The part comes back at the right dimensions and still gets rejected, because the inspection report format was never agreed, or the anodize was supposed to be paid by the buyer, or nobody said the thread is a go/no-go check and not a measurement.
Here are the six things worth pinning down before a drawing leaves your desk. None of them require a factory visit. All of them show up in the first article inspection if you skip them.
1. Is the drawing actually quotable
A drawing can be dimensionally complete and still be hard to quote. Two things cause most of the back-and-forth:
Stacked tolerances on a datum chain. If five dimensions in a row each carry the same tolerance, the last one absorbs the sum. A shop has to either hold everything tighter than marked or ask which feature is functional. Neither is free.
Missing or implied datums. A position callout without a clear datum reference forces the shop to invent one. That invention becomes a conversation after the parts are made.
A five-minute pass over your own drawing before sending it removes most of this. Check that every GD&T frame points at a datum that is actually measurable on the part, not at a surface that gets machined away in the last operation.
2. Material callout: grade is not enough
"6061" is not a specification. 6061-T6 and 6061-T651 have different residual stress, and that difference shows up the moment you thin a wall or face off a plate. One moves, one moves less.
The same applies to stainless. 303 machines freely and is common for turned parts, but it is not 304. 316L is not 316. 17-4 PH comes in different heat treat conditions that machine nothing alike.
Write grade, temper, and any standard the material must meet (ASTM, EN, JIS). If the material is buyer-supplied, say who owns the scrap and how much allowance the shop should plan for. Free-issue material disputes are almost always about allowance, not quality.
3. Surface finish: who does it, who pays freight, who owns rejects
Anodize, passivate, zinc plate, powder coat - most machine shops sub these out. The sub-contractor price is rarely the issue. The issue is the three questions nobody asks:
- Does the quoted price include the finish?
- Who pays freight to and from the finisher?
- If 8 of 200 parts come back with color variation, who eats them?
A shop that quotes finish-inclusive will look more expensive on the sheet and cheaper at the end of the month. Ask for the split explicitly and put the reject rule in the PO.
4. Inspection: what document, what sampling, what happens on a miss
"FAI required" means different things in different shops. It can mean a hand-filled dimensional sheet, or a CMM report with the program attached, or a full PPAP-lite package with material certs and capability numbers.
Decide three things before the order:
- Which dimensions are critical and must be reported.
- Whether you want 100% inspection or AQL sampling, and at what level.
- What the remedy is if a reported dimension is out of tolerance - rework, replace, or concession with deviation.
A shop that asks you these questions before quoting is usually the one that will not surprise you later.
5. Packaging and marking
This is where small orders quietly lose money. A 200-piece lot of polished parts shipped loose in one bag arrives with 30 pieces of cosmetic damage. Nobody specified single-piece wrapping, so nobody is at fault, and everybody is unhappy.
Specify: individual bagging or tray, rust preventive if the material is prone to it, and carton marking that matches your receiving system. If the parts go into an assembly line, ask for kitting by revision.
6. Trade terms: where the risk actually transfers
Terms get copied from an old PO without much thought. The one that causes the most confusion is FOB, because the named port matters and the risk point is not the same as the cost point.
Under EXW, the buyer's responsibility starts at the shop door. Under FOB Shenzhen, it starts when the goods are on board. Under DDP, it ends at your dock - and the seller is carrying duty, clearance, and the tariff classification risk.
Pick the term that matches who is actually good at the middle mile. If you have a forwarder you trust, EXW or FOB is simpler. If you do not, DDP costs more but removes a category of problem.
Whatever you choose, write the Incoterm with the named place and the version year. "FOB" alone has started more arguments than any tolerance callout.
The three-line RFQ
If you want to compress all of this into one email, three lines do most of the work:
- Drawing revision, material grade and temper, quantity and target date.
- Finish in or out, inspection document required, packaging requirement.
- Trade term with named place, and who books freight.
A shop that answers those three lines with specific numbers is telling you something about how it will handle the order. A shop that answers with a range and a phone call is telling you something too.
Written from the shop floor side of the RFQ inbox - the place where these six items either arrive clear or turn into a week of emails.
Top comments (0)