A buyer forwarded me a twelve-page CMM report last month with one line: "So does this part pass or not?"
He'd had the report for two weeks. He'd printed it. He just couldn't tell what the numbers meant.
That's normal. A coordinate measuring machine report is a technical document written for the person who programmed the measurement, not for the person making the purchasing decision. Here's how to read one in about five minutes.
Start at the header, not the data
The first page will have a block of parameters. Four of them matter:
Temperature. CMM measurements are valid at 20 °C. If the part was measured at 26 °C and the report doesn't mention compensation, every dimension on a 100 mm aluminum feature is off by roughly 14 µm — which is larger than a ±0.005 mm tolerance. Not every shop logs this. The ones who do are telling you something about their process.
Probe and stylus. A 2 mm ruby ball cannot measure into a 1 mm hole. If the report shows a small-hole diameter measured with a stylus that physically couldn't fit, the number is extrapolated, not measured.
Program version and date. The report should say when it was run and with what program. A report dated three weeks before the shipment is a report about a different part.
Datum definition. Look at which datum is primary. If the drawing says datum A is the large face and the report uses datum A as the bore, none of the position tolerances mean what you think.
Then find the tolerance column, not the actual column
People read CMM reports by scanning the "Actual" column and comparing to the nominal. That's backwards.
Read the tolerance column first. It tells you what the shop thought you asked for. Then read actual. Then read deviation. The deviation column — actual minus nominal — is where problems show up, because a part can be inside tolerance and still be drifting toward one edge in a way that predicts the next batch will fail.
If you see a column of deviations all positive and near the limit, that's a process trending out, even though nothing is out of spec today.
Understanding what the columns are
A typical line looks like this:
Feature 12 Ø8.000 ±0.010 Actual 8.004 Dev +0.004 Out 0.006 OK
- Nominal and tolerance from the drawing.
- Actual is what the machine found.
- Dev is the signed difference.
- Out (or "Out of Tol") is how much room is left before the limit. Sometimes shown as a percentage.
- Status is the pass/fail.
For position tolerance, the number after ⌀ is a diameter zone, and the actual is usually reported as a diametral deviation, not a radius. Confusing the two is a common misread — a 0.02 position result is a 0.01 radial offset.
GD&T modifiers change the answer
Three modifiers show up constantly and each one changes the arithmetic:
Ⓜ (MMC — maximum material condition). On a position callout, MMC gives you a bonus tolerance. If a hole is at ⌀8.05 when MMC is ⌀8.00, you get 0.05 of extra position tolerance. A report showing a position result that looks over tolerance may be perfectly valid once the bonus is applied. Check whether the report applied it; many don't, and the shop has to explain it manually.
Ⓛ (LMC). Same idea in the other direction, used for wall thickness and clearance.
Ⓟ (projected tolerance zone). Common on threaded holes. The tolerance zone starts above the surface, not at it. If the report measures at the surface, the result is meaningless.
If the report doesn't state which modifiers were applied, ask. It's a two-line email and it's the difference between a real rejection and a misunderstanding.
What CMM can't tell you
Worth knowing before you reject a part based on a report:
- Small deep holes. Below about ⌀2 mm with depth over 5× diameter, the stylus can't reach the bottom properly. Reports may show a value that's really a partial measurement.
- Soft materials. Probe force deforms aluminum and plastics slightly. The measured diameter may not be the free-state diameter.
- Surface finish. CMM gives you geometry, not Ra. A separate surface roughness tester is required.
- Threads. CMM can measure a thread's pitch diameter, but a go/no-go gauge is the functional authority.
- Thin walls. Probing a 0.5 mm wall deflects it.
The five-minute version
If you only have five minutes:
- Check the date and temperature on page one.
- Find the worst deviation. Multiply by two for position tolerances.
- Count how many features are within 20% of the limit — that's your process risk.
- Check whether any failures are MMC-related before you call them failures.
- Look at the datum setup against the drawing.
Then look at the summary line, which most reports put at the end: a count of pass/fail per feature class. If the shop included a CP/CPK column, anything under 1.33 on a critical dimension means the process is capable but not comfortable.
What a good report looks like from the shop side
The one we send includes: measurement temperature and time, stylus configuration, program name and revision, datum callouts matched to the drawing, a ballooned drawing with feature numbers, and every dimension listed — not just the critical ones.
It's four pages for a simple part. Buyers sometimes ask why it's longer than the one they got from the last shop. The answer is that the short one usually had the datum mismatch and the MMC bonus missing.
We ship FAI and CMM reports with the first article, in the buyer's format if requested. What goes in one: chxmetal.cloud/first-article-inspection
Related:
Top comments (0)