A quality manager in Ohio once sent us a supplier questionnaire with 41 questions. Thirty-nine were about capability. Two were about paper: "Do you provide material certification to EN 10204 3.1?" and "What does your CoC state?" Those two questions sank three of the four quotes he had on his desk. Not because the other shops couldn't machine the part — they could, probably better than we can on some geometries — but because nobody on their side had ever been asked to write down what they had done.
That is the gap this post is about. For machined medical components, the machining is the easy half. The traceable half is a stack of documents, and the stack has to be right the first time, because a device file that can't be reconstructed six years later is a recall problem, not a paperwork problem.
One thing up front, so nobody misreads this. We are a contract machining supplier: ISO 9001:2015 and ISO 14001:2015 certified, in Shajing, Bao'an, Shenzhen, since 2013. We are not a certified medical device manufacturer, and we don't market ourselves as one. What follows describes what a machining supplier can legitimately hand over, and where the boundary sits. If a shop tells you they're "certified for medical work" without a certificate number you can look up, that's a red flag, not a selling point.
Why the paper matters more than the tolerance
A 316L bone plate held to ±0.005 mm is a nice piece of machining. A 316L bone plate held to ±0.005 mm with a mill certificate showing heat number, chemistry and mechanicals from the same heat as the bar that went into the machine is a qualified piece of machining. The difference is not quality — it's the ability to answer a question two years later: which lot of material, which machine, which operator, which inspection, which revision of the drawing.
Device makers get audited on that chain. Their suppliers inherit the requirement whether or not they signed up for it. So the practical question for a buyer is not "can you hold the tolerance" but "can you reconstruct the part's history on a Tuesday afternoon in 2031."
The four documents that carry the weight
1. Material certificate (mill cert). Issued by the mill or the stockist, not by the machine shop. The useful version is EN 10204 3.1: specific to the delivered lot, with heat number, chemical composition and mechanical properties. A 2.2 certificate is a test report without independent verification of the lot — acceptable for some industrial work, usually not for implant-adjacent components. What to check: the heat number on the cert matches the heat number on the material label in the shop's incoming record, and the grade matches what the drawing calls out (316L vs 316 is not a rounding difference; nor is Ti-6Al-4V ELI vs standard Grade 5).
2. Certificate of Conformance (CoC). Issued by the machine shop, on their letterhead, signed. It states that the parts conform to the drawing revision and the purchase order, and it names the standards the process was run to. This is where shops get sloppy. A CoC that says "parts manufactured to customer drawing" and nothing else is nearly worthless; a usable one lists drawing revision, material heat, quantity, relevant process specs (passivation per ASTM A967, for example), and who signed it.
3. First Article Inspection report (FAI). The dimensional evidence: every characteristic on the drawing, measured, with the instrument used and the actual value, plus material and process certifications attached. For a new part, this is the document that stops a bad run before it becomes 5,000 bad parts. What to check: ballooned drawing matches the report line by line, values sit inside tolerance with margin, and any characteristic that was reworked is noted — a silent rework is the thing auditors hunt for.
4. Traceability record tying it together. Not usually a document you receive, but one you should ask to see once: the shop's internal traveler or route card linking material heat → work order → machine → operator → inspection results → shipment. If a shop can't produce that on request, the three documents above are decoration.
Where a machining supplier's accountability ends
This is the part of the conversation that gets skipped, and it's the part that causes trouble later.
| Item | Who owns it | What a machine shop can honestly say |
|---|---|---|
| Design validation, risk analysis (ISO 14971) | Device manufacturer | Not our scope |
| Biocompatibility testing (ISO 10993) | Device manufacturer | Not our scope — we don't test for it |
| Sterility, packaging validation | Device manufacturer / contract sterilizer | Not our scope |
| Medical device QMS certification | Device manufacturer or contract manufacturer | We hold ISO 9001:2015 only — anything else must be on a certificate you can verify |
| Material chemistry and heat identity | Mill / stockist, passed through | Yes — with the mill cert, unaltered |
| Dimensional conformity to drawing | Machine shop | Yes — with FAI and in-process inspection records |
| Process certifications (e.g. passivation) | Machine shop or its approved subcontractor | Yes, if named on the CoC — ask before the PO, not after |
| Cleanliness / particulate on delivery | Shared, must be specified | Only to the level written into the PO |
The pattern: the further a requirement sits from the metal, the less a machine shop can carry it. A shop that agrees to "handle the ISO 10993 side" is either misunderstanding you or planning to subcontract it without telling you.
The details that actually trip up a first order
A few specifics that come up repeatedly, all of them cheap to fix if raised before the quote and expensive afterwards:
- Drawing revision control. If the drawing arrives without a revision letter, the first thing we do is ask. Parts machined to rev A while the buyer's file is at rev C is the most common documented nonconformance in this category, and it's nobody's malice — just silence.
- Material grade ambiguity. 316L, 316, 17-4PH in conditions H900 vs H1025, Ti-6Al-4V vs ELI. These are different materials with different certs. A drawing that says "stainless" isn't a specification.
- Surface finish callouts. "Smooth" is not a callout. Ra 0.8 µm on a sealing face and Ra 0.8 µm on a bracket are different cost conversations; the finish also drives whether passivation alone is enough or electropolishing is needed.
- Passivation spec by name. ASTM A967 covers chemical passivation; specify the type. A CoC that says "passivated" without citing the spec is unverifiable.
- Burr and edge criteria. "Deburr all edges" means a different thing to a deburring bench and to a customer finding a 0.05 mm roll on a mating face.
What the numbers look like in practice
| Parameter | What we run | Notes for a medical-adjacent RFQ |
|---|---|---|
| Tolerance | ±0.005 mm; ±0.005 mm or better on request; ISO 2768-m where the drawing is looser | State which applies — mixed callouts invite disputes |
| Prototype lead time | 3–7 days | Includes FAI on request, not just the parts |
| Production lead time | 7–15 days | Longer if passivation or a subcontract process is in the chain |
| Surface finishing | 3–7 days | Passivation, anodize, electropolish via approved partners |
| Minimum order | 1 piece, stepped pricing above | A single prototype with full paperwork is a normal order here |
| Shop floor | 220 machines: 100 machining centers (30 of them 3+2), 50 CNC lathes, 70 Tsugami Swiss-types | Swiss-types handle the Ø1–20 mm small-diameter work |
| Footprint / people | 5,000 m², 100+ staff, 13 years | Enough capacity to keep a device program's volume ramp inside one shop |
| Trade term | EXW Shenzhen | We'll recommend freight forwarders we've shipped with; the export leg stays with your forwarder |
The honest summary
If you're sourcing machined medical components from China, sort suppliers by their paperwork before you sort them by price. Ask for a sample CoC and a sample FAI on the first email. The shops that send them without being chased are the ones whose process is already under control; the ones that say "yes of course, after the PO" are telling you where their documentation sits in the priority list.
And be suspicious of anyone who claims a certification they can't produce a number for. We'd rather lose a quote than put a standard on our letterhead that we can't back with a certificate.
CHX Precision Metal is a contract machining supplier in Shajing, Bao'an, Shenzhen — founded 2013, 5,000 m², 100+ staff, 220 CNC machines, ISO 9001:2015 and ISO 14001:2015. If you're putting together a supplier file for a machined component and want to see what our CoC and FAI actually look like before you commit to a quote, send the drawing through the RFQ form on chxmetal.com.
Related reading
More notes from the same shop floor, for buyers comparing processes or suppliers:
Top comments (0)