Our larger branches have a saw that cuts timber to customers' sizes, and about a third of our timber leaves the yard cut. For years the saw operators planned each day's cuts themselves, with a pencil and a great deal of experience. In 2024 we bought optimisation software that takes the day's cut orders from the trading system and produces a cutting plan with as little waste as possible. Offcut waste fell from about nine per cent to under four, and on paper the project paid for itself within a year.
That spring, roofers began complaining that our Leeds branch never had six metre lengths. The branch had bought more six metre timber than ever. It was all going through the saw.
The software had done exactly what it was asked. Long lengths almost always produce less waste than short ones, because more combinations of cuts fit into them, so it reached for six metre and five point four metre lengths for nearly every plan. By its own measure it was excellent. It had no idea that a six metre length is worth more than its metres. We charge more per metre for long lengths because they are scarcer and some jobs cannot use anything shorter. The operators had always kept them back for those customers without anyone asking them to. That was never written down, so it was never configured.
Meanwhile shorter lengths piled up in the racks, and the replenishment job, which looked only at sales and not at what the saw consumed, kept ordering more of them. When finance compared timber margins with the year before, the waste saving had been more than cancelled out by long lengths sold at short length prices, and by whole lengths we could not sell because we had none.
The software already allowed a value for each stock length and a minimum stock below which a length would not be used for cutting, and we set both. What the saw consumes now feeds the replenishment job alongside sales. And the operator reviews each plan before the first cut, with the right to override it, which he does about twice a week.
An optimiser will chase the number you give it and spend anything you have not priced to get there. Before you hand a decision to software, ask the person who used to make it what else they were protecting.
– Serguey Shinder
Top comments (0)