Last year our company was bought by a larger building materials group. I was told under a confidentiality agreement about seven weeks before completion and asked for a list of our material IT contracts for the buyer's lawyers. I sent a list of suppliers, annual costs and renewal dates, which is what our contract register held.
The lawyers sent back a question I could not answer from that list. Which of these contracts have change of control clauses?
A change of control clause gives one party rights when ownership of the other changes. In a software licence it usually lets the supplier end the contract, or requires its consent before the licence can carry on or be transferred to the new owner. Suppliers include it so that a customer cannot pass a licence to a competitor by being bought. It is common, it is usually on page twenty something, and I had never been asked about it.
We read every contract over twenty thousand pounds a year. Five had such a clause. Two suppliers waived theirs with a letter. Two more asked for an administration fee. The fifth was our warehouse management system, which runs every depot we have, and its supplier was entitled to end our licence on ninety days' notice once the deal completed.
The supplier did not threaten to end it. It offered to consent if we moved to its current licensing model, which priced by site rather than by user, at an annual cost thirty eight percent higher than we were paying. We had ninety days and no alternative system, and the buyer had already planned to move two more of its own warehouses onto ours. We negotiated it down to twenty two percent with a five year price cap. That was a cost of the acquisition that appeared in nobody's model, because nobody had asked IT until the lawyers did.
Our contract register now records, for every contract, whether it has a change of control clause, whether it can be transferred, and which company in our group it names. Before any renewal we try to remove the clause or cap what consent can cost.
A software contract is an asset that a buyer will look at, and the supplier is the one who decides what it is worth on the day ownership changes. Know which of yours can be reopened before someone else asks.
– Serguey Shinder
Top comments (0)