Three of our depots have weighbridges, and every lorry of sand, gravel and aggregate that comes in is weighed full and empty. The ticket the weighbridge prints is our record of what we received, and our quarry suppliers invoice against it.
The weighbridge software is old but reliable. It writes each ticket as a rich text file and then asks Windows to print it. It does not print the file itself. It hands it to whichever program Windows has registered for rich text files, and on our weighbridge PCs that had always been WordPad, the basic word processor that came with Windows.
Microsoft announced in 2023 that WordPad was being retired, and it is not part of Windows 11 from version 24H2 onwards. It cannot be installed again. Our weighbridge PCs were upgraded to 24H2 in our spring rollout, and the rollout passed every test we ran: the PCs started, signed in, reached the network and opened the weighbridge software, which weighed lorries perfectly.
Nobody tested a ticket. The weighbridge PCs have the frontline Microsoft 365 licence, which includes the web and mobile versions of Office but not desktop Word, so once WordPad had gone nothing on those machines could print a rich text file. The software caught the error, wrote it to a log file and carried on. Drivers were waved off without tickets, and the weighbridge operators assumed the printer was playing up again.
It took eleven days and a dispute over two hundred tonnes of sharp sand before anyone rang us. The weights were still in the weighbridge database, so we could reprint every ticket, but the quarry had already queried a week of invoices.
We changed three things. Before each Windows feature update, someone now reads Microsoft's list of removed features and checks each one against what our depot software does behind the scenes, not only against what users open themselves. Our upgrade tests are written as business tasks, so the weighbridge test is now to weigh a lorry and hand the driver a ticket. And the weighbridge supplier has changed the software to raise an alarm on the operator's screen when a ticket fails to print.
An upgrade can take away something no person ever opened, because a program was quietly using it. Test the work people do, not the applications they launch.
– Serguey Shinder
Top comments (0)